Enjoy Your Fireplace

With A

Fireplace Renovation

A fireplace is not unchangeable. What prospects are there for changing yours?
If you don’t like the looks of your fireplace, virtually every aspect of its appearance can be changed.
Click on any of the large icons above to learn how various surfaces and materials can be altered.

What Can be Done with an Unattractive Fireplace?


These days we have at our disposal tremendous products that can be used to modify the appearance of all kinds of surfaces, including most of the surfaces typically found on fireplaces. Couple those products with some creativity and your fireplace can receive a whole new aura.

Explore this site, surface by surface to come up with a solid plan for your unit. For each different surface, you’ll see a variety of options for modification. For inspiration, you might try exploring the Gallery page of the Color Craftsmen website. “The Color Craftsmen” is the name of a company that performs fireplace makeovers for customers, most of whom are in the St. Louis, Missouri vicinity. However, on this Fireplace Renovations site, you can learn about the kind of changes you’d like to make to your fireplace, with or without help from any contracting company.

Prospective Changes to Your Fireplace Include

No one style of fireplace pleases everyone. If your fireplace doesn’t look good, we can help.

We offer a variety of options for fireplaces of any style and constructed of any material.

Add or Remove elements

Add an overmantel

Clean off soot

Home Page 1IMG_1054

Before & Afters

Changing the look of your fireplace is a live prospect. Take a look at what has been done with other fireplaces and come up with a plan for a new look for your unit.

We are proud members of these associations

What can be done with Brick?


Clean your brick with a non-sudsing cleaner. Often some soot will remain. If it does, consider staining the affected bricks in their original color to achieve a clean look. Also, use a second stain; one that matches the color of clean mortar.
Home Page 2IMG_4343

Color Change:

Home Page 3IMG_4349
Another option would be to change the color of your brick. There are several ways to do that with stain, paint or Limewash.

Staining & Painting:

Whether you use stain or paint as a first coat, your objective is to apply a base color. You might or might not choose to add more layers. Consider varying the color of individual bricks. Use either a dry-brush technique or a thin wash of color to vary the look of each brick.


There are many different ways to do a lime wash. You might put it on and rub it off; leave some areas unpainted or even thin your limewash for a unique look. Any color is feasible except very dark ones.

Limewash Examples

Home Page 4image1

Fireplace Remodeling Experts

You’re in charge of the budget and the design as you lead our artisan to improve the look of your fireplace! Need ideas? No problem, we have lots of them. Our process helps customers decide on the best look for any uninspiring fireplace.

Mulling Bricks:

Home Page 5IMG_4358
Mull bricks together with a sand-free engineered cement and then paint to look like stone.

Smooth Over:

Smooth over brick, then paint or apply decorative plaster.

Project Example:

Brick smoothed over and painted. (In this case, painted to resemble marble.)
Home Page 6smoothOver2

Covering Brick:

Below are examples of stone tile:

Stone Tile & Veneer:

Stone Tile and Stone Veneer are two options for covering brick. Shop for either at big box stores like Menards or Lowe’s. For greater selection, try a tile shop for stone tile or a purveyor of stone veneer.

Below are examples of Stone Veneer

What kinds of plaster exist?

Click on any image to zoom in:

Learn More Today When You Call us!

What can be done with Stone?


If your stone has accumulated soot, try removing it with a non-sudsing cleaner. Usually, some soot remains. You could try thinning some paint down to make it a stain. It’ll be mostly water.

It should be the same color as the clean stone. Judiciously apply it over the soot to hide the soot. (You may need a few colors for the stones. Often they’re not a single color. Also, the mortar may need its own distinct color.)
Home Page 7stonecleaning2

Color Change:

Home Page 8recolorstone6
It’s feasible to change the color of stone. Thin paints in your choice of new colors. (Be careful not to choose colors that wouldn’t be found in nature.)

After the paint dries it’s helpful to apply one or more washes to stones (paints thinned to the consistency of water.) it’s good to use wash colors that lean towards cool tones as well as others that lean towards warm tones. Plan to use a round brush to recolor mortar lines.
Home Page 9IMG_0111

Stone Repair:

Stone can be repaired, modified or covered. I recommend a non-sanded engineered cement for repairs. Without sand it can be readily sanded smooth once it’s dry.

It’s possible to modify a stone fireplace by filling voids or adding more bulk where needed. Imagine a fireplace made of volcanic rock. All of those pinholes could be filled with a non-sanded engineered cement to create smoother stone.
Home Page 10stonerepair2
Home Page 11IMG_0144

What can be done with Wood?

Wood offers many options for change. Don’t suppose that your only option is to cover it up with paint. Usually, people want to keep the grain. Fortunately, we have wonderful products available today. Two kinds of product are feasible for adding a translucent layer of color without altogether obscuring the grain.


The first is an oil-based product call “Gel Stain”. Don’t apply it like paint, you want to spread it far. I recommend using a cheap chip brush to spread the product as thinly as possible. Experiment first on a sample board or on an inconspicuous area.

A second option would be use a waterbased stain that is suitable for sealed surfaces. (Be sure to check with the manufacturer; most stains need to go only on raw wood.). Use the same method as above. Practice first because it’s a bit tricky working with a product that dries quickly.
Same surface with a thin, translucent layer of water-based stain, manufactured to adhere even to a sealed surface. Note that the grain is somewhat obscured, but not altogether:
Home Page 12IMG_5472


Home Page 13IMG_5891

Stained & Sealed Wood:

In some cases, people might want a stained piece of wood to look aged without looking decrepit. Purposely disguising some of the grain with a darker color is a way to age a piece.

In this example, the same piece of wood with dark, translucent stain is applied only to edges:


It is possible to lighten the color of wood or to make materials other than wood look like wood. It requires a few steps and requires careful work.

The first step is to paint the surface a color similar to the lightest color you want to see in your wood. Use a satin sheen and let it dry overnight. Your goal is to have a surface that does not “grip” the next coat before you can manipulate it.
Next, create a glaze that is darker. A glaze is a translucent coat that has just a bit of colorant in it. Apply that and drag something through it in order to create some subtle, fine lines all across the piece.

When that is dry, you might like to add the step of using an artist’s brush to paint in some darker grain lines. Examine photographs of wood online to see how grain looks in the species of wood that you want to replicate. It’s good to obscure the edges of these grain lines by gently dragging a comb or a nylon brush or a soft bristle brush (or all of these) across the paint before it dries.

When that’s dry, it’s good to coat the work with a layer of very translucent glaze that’s neither as light as the base coat, nor as dark as the second layer. This helps to blend the colors together. Finally, clear, protective coats should be applied to protect your work.

You might drag a stiff brush through the glaze or a piece of burlap wrapped around a piece of cardboard. The torn edge of a piece of pasteboard might even work. Alternatively, look for a plastic or rubber tool made for this purpose. A popular one is called "Roller Rocker".
Home Page 14IMG_3613

Strip and Refinish:

Home Page 15IMG_5186
If wood is degraded and you want to revive it, a good option is to strip it and re-stain it.

If it’s painted, consider using a safe, water-based striping chemical to remove the bulk of the paint. After clear-coat or paint is removed, sand the surface by hand or with an electric sander until the surface has a consistent, clean color.

Stain with a color of your choice and apply clear coats.

What can be done with Tile?


Tile can be painted. If it has a sheen, it should first be cleaned and then sanded in order to provide the paint a better chance to grip onto the surface. Some fireplaces generate a lot of heat. Please take that into consideration when selecting paint products. Investigate whether the paint you select can handle the heat.

For very dense or shiny tiles, it’s recommended to using a primer that is advertised as offering high adhesion. After that’s dry, apply heat resistant paint. Below is a sample. We applied a darker color on the grout in an effort to help create a more authentic appearance for the tiles.
When painting tile, it’s often better to use more than a single color. Here are samples of painted tile which employ multiple colors:

Below, tape was used to cover grout joints. Rubbing alcohol was sprinkled on wet water-based paint to help create natural-looking color breaks on individual tiles.
A third way to color painted tile would be to add some vein lines. The viscosity of the dark-colored paint need to be thin. Care needs to be taken to not have tremendous contrast between the colors, lest the appearance not look unnatural. Vary the width of the veins. They can be interrupted rather than constant. Apply with an artist brush or even with a feather. You might choose to use a second, wide, very soft-bristled brush to lightly draw across the slightly wet veins, moving perpendicularly to the veins. This softens them, making them blend in. It’s best to develop your skills for this procedure on a practice surface before attempting it on your tile.
Home Page 16IMG_0336
For greater variety, use different base colors from one tile to another.

Vary the color, style and direction of the veins too.

Smooth Over:

Below, a “rim” – made of 1/2 inch cement board – was added to the perimeter of a hearth. Then the top surface was filled and covered with self-leveling cement before being colored with two tones of gray, applied wet on wet and blended.
Home Page 17Screen Shot 2021-12-16 at 2.37.39 PM
Home Page 18Screen Shot 2021-12-16 at 2.07.32 PM
Below, red quarry tile was cleaned, sanded, filled and covered with cement. Next it was coated with a polished plaster which was burnished to bring out highlights.

What can be done with marble?

Wood offers many options for change. Don’t suppose that your only option is to cover it up with paint. Usually, people want to keep the grain. Fortunately, we have wonderful products available today. Two kinds of product are feasible for adding a translucent layer of color without altogether obscuring the grain.


Many people are interested in swapping out the green marble on their fireplace for some other color. One tremendous option is to recolor the existing marble rather than remove and replace it. This process was developed in Europe centuries ago and has been used in spectacular palaces, churches and mansions ever since. Benefits include infinite color options, avoidance of unfortunate blotches that Mother Nature sometimes allows, speed of transformation, etc.

Below are Before and After shots of a Green to Brown transformation and includes photos of preparation.
Home Page 19index-min
Procedure is similar to the preparation of tile, listed above; clean and sand, tack to remove dust. Prime with high adhesion primer. Apply heat resistant base coat. Paint in veins with artist brush and/or a feather. Thin vein color to allow for translucency. Vary color, size and direction of veins. (Study photos of real marble.) Soften fresh veins with very soft bristle brush. Apply heat-resistant clear coats.

Marble, painted brown and veined:

Removal & rEPLACEMENT:

Finally, marble can be removed and replaced with another material. In this case, brick veneer was installed in its place:
Home Page 20index11

What can be done with mantels?


A mantel can be removed. Any holes that remain after removal can be patched and blended in.


The mantel can be replaced with a mantel of a different style.

Here, a mantel was removed, stone was added to the surface and thin shelves were attached as an alternative to a bulky mantel.
Home Page 21indexr311
Home Page 22index15
Here is an example of another style change. Here, 1950’s style stair-step mantel shelves were swapped out for a beam mantel:

After shelves were removed, the resulting scars were addressed and colored before the beam was installed.


Sometimes a mantel can have elements added as in this project, where a more substantial mantel was desired:
Home Page 23IMG_1054
In this next case – along with other extensive changes – an element in the center of the horizontal portion of the mantel was removed so as to make a less substantial mantel:


In this next example, one mantel was removed and was replaced with another of similar dimensions. The tile was also covered and colored.
Home Page 24index3
Here’s a second example of style change as one mantel was removed and replaced with another:


Finally, it may be appropriate to have a carpenter create a custom mantel for your fireplace as in this example of a newly constructed fireplace. This one was created out of wood but was given a stone -like finish:
Home Page 25index1
Besides altering the shape of a mantel, the color can also be changed. An option in addition to re-staining and to painting is to cover with a synthetic plaster that creates the look of stone, as in this project. Routed-molding portions of the mantel were removed in favor of pieces with square corners. Then the acrylic stone finish was applied with small trowels and putty knives:

Add a Beam Mantel:

While most traditional mantels have included both horizontal and vertical elements, a beam mantel is another option. They can be rustic or refined. There is currently a trend that favors the rustic variety.

The beam might include supports as in this example:

Stain it dark:

A beam can be created out of a 6”x6”x8’ cedar beam, often available at home improvement stores.

Stain it light:

A beam can be created out of a 6”x6”x8’ cedar beam, often available at home improvement stores.


You might choose to purchase a beam reclaimed from an old barn:

Click on either photo to view in full resolution.

Purchase online:

Click on either photo to view in full resolution.

What can be done with Hearths?


A hearth can be removed. A new hearth can be made out of self-leveling cement, which is later decorated.


Home Page 26index3
Another option would be to paint a hearth to look like marble.
Painted brick can be basecoated with paint which is the color you want your new brick to have. You might choose to use several colors that are similar. Next, use a dry brush technique to alter the color of the new paint colors.
Home Page 27IMG_7247


Home Page 28index5

Limewash was applied and then rubbed off in some areas. Sometimes a slightly different color of Limewash can be employed for variation.

Replacement & Removal:

A hearth can be removed and replaced with other materials as here. A marble slab was removed. brick veneer was then installed and grouted.
Home Page 29index17

What can be done with overmantels?

An “overmantel” is typically an architectural feature that is attached to the wall, rather than hung on the wall. So, while a picture or a mirror might be hung above a mantel, those items are MNF not called an overmantel. Often an overmantel is made of wood, either shiplap planks or – in a more rustic presentation – reclaimed boards. Below are examples. Originally, all of these had plaster or drywall above the mantel.
We might stretch the definition of “overmantel “to include a painted finish, so long as the finish (decorative paint, burnished plaster or even plain paint) creates contrast with the rest of the walls in the room.

Decorative paint effect over a mantel:
Polished plaster, surrounding a mantel:
Coarse textured plaster above and below the mantel:
Stone tile above and below a mantel:
NOTE: Both of the fireplaces immediately above are included here because, originally, the fireplace stopped at the mantel. There was nothing decorative above it.
Sometimes an overmantel includes molding made of wood or plaster. It typically relates to the mantel in color or form.
Below, a recessed area above a mantel received a decorative plaster finish:

What can be done with doors?

Bright brass doors have fallen out of favor with some homeowners. Fortunately, these can be painted with spray paints which are heat resistant. First, the surface should be sanded with very fine sandpaper. Wipe off the Sanding dust that remains. Next, mask off all areas that are not to receive paint.

Finally, I recommend using two different – but related – colors of paint. Deftly spray in such a way that neither color predominates and both blend into one another. This approach helps to keep the surface from looking painted. Below is an example, including some close-up shots.
One exception to the above rule of using more than one color is when darkening the brass to have a black finish. In this project, the bright brass was sanded with very fine sandpaper and then cleaned and masked.

Satin black high heat paint can either be sprayed onto the surface or applied by brush. Brushing yields a thicker coat but might leave brushstrokes.
Home Page 30index2